Football, seen through the middle.
Monday 16 November 2026
News

Premier League panel rules failure to punish Timber was wrong

The Premier League’s five-person KMI panel has decided, by a 4:1 vote, that the decision not to penalise Timber for an incident in a recent match was incorrect.

On Wednesday, the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents panel judged that the decision not to punish Timber for an incident in a recent match was incorrect. This one comes via James Pearce, who reports the conclusion followed a post-match review of the footage.

The five-person group delivered a 4:1 majority verdict on the call, indicating a clear majority felt the on-field outcome should have been different.

The KMI process is a retrospective assessment of significant refereeing decisions. Its determinations state whether a call was right or wrong after study, but they are evaluations rather than fresh disciplinary actions.

The ruling does not alter the result of the game and does not in itself impose a sanction; it recognises that the incident should have been penalised at the time. It could nonetheless feed into internal reflections on officiating standards and interpretations for future matches.

Further specifics beyond the verdict, such as the exact match details and any subsequent administrative steps, were not set out in the reporting.

Share
Midfielder Editorial Team

Midfielder is written and edited by a single desk. Competition rules, dates and financial figures are checked against primary sources, and every changeable fact is linked. How we work.

OCEAN LUX LTD, registered in England and Wales no. 16013082. Registered office: 27 Old Gloucester St, Holborn, London, United Kingdom, WC1N 3AX. info@midfielder.co.uk